Bible Books Doctrines Words Lord Jesus Christ Messages Hermey Salvation Humm Site Help |
search tips | advanced search |
This is a high-level reference document. In most cases, this document provides links to more detailed notes within the Book Studies for the Gospel accounts. Those notes provide the detailed explanation of what is reported as well as providing contextual considerations and references to other places which deal with the details. Therefore, do not consider this document to be the complete reference to any given incident which is reported within the Bible.
There are certain categories of events, such as miracles, which are reported in other documents and, usually, are not reported in another document even if the event could be reported in other categories from the one where it is reported. If everything were reported everywhere it is possible, there would be a lot of duplication. Therefore, if you do not find what you are looking for in this document, then click on the Doctrines Main Menu item and search the other documents accessed from that web page.
The detailed incidents, which are reported, of the life and ministry of Jesus
are in all Gospel accounts. However, not all details are reported and people who believe that everything is reported are being foolish. In addition, the details, which are reported, vary between the different Gospels accounts because the different authors present different points of view. There are no conflicts between the Gospels on these incidents.
One reason that people claim that there are conflicts or errors is because of the erroneous assumption that the Gospel accounts are in a strict time sequence. While all of them usually keep time sequence within the reporting of a given incident, the incidents are not necessarily reported in a strict time sequence and, definitely, there are times when an incident is reported in one, apparent, time sequence within one Gospel account, but the same incident is reported in a different, apparent, time sequence within another Gospel account.
The reason for this is that each Gospel author wrote his Gospel to deliver a certain message about Jesus
and every Gospel delivers a different message. Each Gospel has a number of chapters and each chapter has a different theme with the various themes put together in the order which supports the message of that particular Gospel. Within each chapter, each author reports incidents, from the life of Jesus
, which support the theme of that particular chapter. And, some incidents support more than one theme. Therefore, the particular incident is reported in a given Gospel within the chapter which has the theme which that incident supports.
An example of what was just written is the fact that the 'Parable of the Hirelings Killing the Heir' is reported in Mark 12:2-11, where the chapter theme is: 'Correction of popular doctrinal error'. The same parable is reported in Luke 20:9-19, where the chapter theme is: 'The Religious Leaders Challenge Jesus'. Not only are the themes different but the chapter numbers are significantly different. Further, the details reported are also different because the emphasis of each author is different. No, there are no conflicts between the reporting of various incidents within the Gospels. There just can be a different perspective of the incident reported by different authors. Anyone who claims that there are errors or conflicts has believed a lie and has failed to verify the truth before repeating the lie, or they used the wrong way to interpret God's perfect word
and then blamed God's perfect word
for their own error.
All of this comes down to something very simple. None of the Gospel accounts were written in a strict time sequence. People who claim that there are errors because different Gospel accounts are in different time sequences are as foolish as someone claiming that a car was nor designed properly because it sank in the water instead of floating like a boat.
We can not be precise in the time sequence of most incidents which occur before Jesus
went to Jerusalem for the last time, which was just before His crucifixion. Therefore, the best way to synchronize the events of the early ministry of Jesus
is by specifics of incidents reported and maintain flexibility about the time sequence with the knowledge that we are not given enough information to be precise with the time sequence of the early ministry. However, once Jesus
did start towards Jerusalem and His crucifixion, we can find the strict time sequence. Doing so is not simple nor is it easy. This is one reason why there have been time sequences published which contain errors.
In Luke 13:31-35 Jesus
pronounced judgment that would come upon Jerusalem because of the crucifixion. This is the start of events, in Luke's Gospel account, when we can know the actual time sequence of events. In the other Gospel accounts, we can not be sure of the time sequence until Jesus
arrives in Jerusalem for the last time.
There are many incidents in the early ministry of Jesus
that we can not specify exactly when they occurred in a time sequence. The various Gospel accounts do not provide sufficient details for us to accurately specify a time sequence. In addition, trying to do so can be adding to the word of God
, which can bring us a curse, and our doing this addition can become the basis of someone claiming that there are errors or conflicts in the Bible when they find an indication of a different time sequence than what some commentator specified. Therefore, there are many incidents, which are part of the early ministry of Jesus
, but which are not reported in this section. The next paragraph gives links to where these events in the early ministry of Jesus
can be found and those sections give the probable time sequence when the absolute time sequence can not be determined.
If the incident is reported in more than one Gospel account, and the exact time sequence is difficult to determine, then the links to it can be found in the Harmony Section of the Significant Gospel Events document. This allows the reader to find where the same incident is reported in more than one Gospel account even if the exact time sequence is difficult to determine. If the incident is only reported in one of the Gospel accounts, and the exact time sequence is difficult to determine, then the link to it can be found in the Significant Events Reported only Once Within the Gospels Section of the Significant Gospel Events document.
In addition to the prior note, there are some incidents where we can specify the time sequence in general, but the time sequence of the details is not important. In those cases, there may be a general note in this section but the reader must access the Harmony Section of the Significant Gospel Events document for links to the details. Certain events and details of events are repeated here when there is no question about the time sequence of those incidents.
In many cases, people are not questioning the time sequence but need to know where to find the incident within each Gospel account. Since there is no need to show the time sequence, those incidents may not be reported here in order to avoid duplication. For example, the birth of Jesus
is reported at / near the start of three Gospel accounts and no one had a problem figuring out the time sequence of that event in the life of Jesus
. Yes, there is a note below about the general subject, and when it occurred in the time sequence, but the reporting of all of the details is in that other document because there is no question about the time sequence at the detail level.
Jesus Christ. Each of these presentations take a different perspective. John presents the spiritual view. Matthew presents the legal view and his enology traces through Joseph, who is the adoptive, and legal, father of
Jesusbut not the physical father. Luke presents the physical view and his genealogy traces through Mary, who is the physical mother of
Jesusbut is not recognized under Jewish Law because she is female. Each Gospel author reveals the perspective of his Gospel with this opening event. Matthew 1:1-17 occurs first, in time sequence, because it provides the list of the legal ancestors of
Jesus Christbefore His birth. Matthew 1:18 starts with
Now the birth of Jesus Christ was on this wise. Luke 1 has the account of the birth of John the Baptist and occurs, time wise, between Matthew 1:17 and Matthew 1:18. Then Matthew 1:18-25 occur. After those events, we have the events of Luke 2:1 through the first phrase of Luke 2:39.
Jesus. And, these chapters can be confusing. Luke 2:39, which says:
And when they had performed all things according to the law of the Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Nazareth. That was eight days after the birth. However, Matthew 2 says that the king sent the wise men to Bethlehem and, Matthew 2:9 says
When they had heard the king, they departed; and, lo, the star, which they saw in the east, went before them, till it came and stood over where the young child was.. Then, after they left, Matthew 2:13 says
And when they were departed, behold, the angel of the Lord appeareth to Joseph in a dream, saying, Arise, and take the young child and his mother, and flee into Egypt, and be thou there until I bring thee word: for Herod will seek the young child to destroy him. Therefore, either the star led the wise men to Nazareth or, for some reason, Joseph and Mary returned to Bethlehem before the wise men arrived. Either could have happened. This ambiguity is one reason why people claim that there are conflicts rather than figuring out whayt could have happened so that all Bible accounts are accurate.
Jesus. The ministry of John the Baptist starts before the ministry of
Jesus. Most of the life of John the Baptist occurs before the early ministry of
Jesusis complete. The Doctrinal Study called John the Baptist has links to every place, in the Bible, where he is mentioned. The Book Studies on the various Gospel accounts provide the time sequence of where the ministry of John the Baptist and the minister of
Jesusoverlap. Those Studies also explain why certain sequences are important to know in order to truly understand the cause-and-effect.
Jesusare dealt with in the Harmony section. (The baptism immediately preceded the temptation.) The comparison of the details for the temptation of
Jesusis found in the note for Luke 4:1.
Jesus. There is nothing before John 1:19 which gives us something to use as the basis of specifying a time for the events reported. The first event in John's gospel, which can be used to place a time to the event, is John 1:28 and then we would have to use the inaccurate history written by men. However, John 1:29 says:
The next day John seeth Jesus coming unto him, and saith, Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the worldand the words of John the Baptist continue for several sentences and include the comment of:
John bare record, saying, I saw the Spirit descending from heaven like a dove, and it abode upon him. Since this event happened at the baptism of
Jesus, and since John's comment is past-tense (
I saw), this event in the Gospel of John happened after the baptism of
Jesus. Further, since the temptation of
Jesushappened immediately after His baptism, and since He was not seen by men until after His temptation was complete, this event in the Gospel of John also happened after the temptation of
Jesus.
Jesusstarted His ministry.
Jesusbegins His ministry, and starts it in Nazareth of Galilee, as reported in Matthew 4:12-17 and Mark 1:14-15 and Luke 4:14-15. That was the town which His family lived in. Matthew starts his account, of the start of the ministry by
Jesus, with a prophecy from Isaiah 9:1-2, which explains why He left Nazareth and moved to Capernaum. That is where He selected His first Disciples (Matthew 4:18-22; Mark 1:16-20; Luke 5:1-12). In Luke 5:27-32, we read that
Jesuscalled Matthew. However, we need to be very careful about assuming that the sequence found within the Gospel accounts is a time sequence, especially with Luke's Gospel. As explained in the note for Luke 1:57, Luke's order is to provide understanding and he sometimes reports events which happen later in time before events which happen earlier in time. This is so that he can group events together which support the point that he is making. We see this again with Luke reporting
Jesuscalling His first disciples after reporting events which actually happened after
Jesuscalled His first disciples. That is: Luke 5:1-12 actually occurred at an earlier time than some of the events in Luke 4 but Luke reports events out of time-sequence so that he can group similar events together.
Jesusministered in Capernaum before He moved there. John 2:2 reports
And both Jesus was called, and his disciples, to the marriage. Therefore, this was after
Jesushad ministered in Capernaum and called at least His first four disciples. In addition, John 2:11 reports
This beginning of miracles did Jesus in Cana of Galilee. Therefore, this occurred before any of the miracles reported by other Gospel accounts. However, He, apparently, ministered in Capernaum, then He returned to Nazareth and preached there and the order of His travel between the two towns in not clear. What is clear is that He had ministered in Capernaum, and done miracles there (Luke 4:23), before He returned to Nazareth where He announced that he was God's
Messiah / Christ(Luke 4:16-30), which is when the people tried to kill Him (Luke 4:28-30). He then returned to Capernaum (Matthew 4:23; Luke 4:31).
Jesus, apparently, moved to Capernaum, if He had not already done so. The Gospel accounts do not tell us when that happened but He appears to avoid Nazareth, to a large extent, after with the exception of visiting His physical family.
Jesusmade Capernaum His base of operations. The people wanted Him to stay there so that He would do miracles for them. They were too selfish to care about the needs of others and they ignore the doctrine of
Jesusand the evidence that He was God's
Messiah / Christ.
Jesusdid not rebuke them for their attitude, because it would do no good. Instead, He told them
I must preach the kingdom of God to other cities also: for therefore am I sentand He, then,
preached in the synagogues of Galilee. It is after this, in Luke 5:1-12, that Luke tells us about
Jesuscalling His first disciples. The Harmony section gives the matching accounts in the other Gospels and Table of Miracles in the Gospels about this, and similar, miracles.
Jesushealed a man of leprosy. The account in Mark 1:40-45 may very well be the same incident. At a minimum, the accounts in Mark and Luke occur at the same general time. However, the account in ` is definitely a different incident done at a different time.
Jesuscure him of
palsy. The Harmony section gives the matching accounts in the other Gospels and the Table of Miracles in the Gospels about this, and similar, miracles.
great multitudes came together to hear, and to be healed by him of their infirmities. Please see the Table of Miracles in the Gospels for links to these incidents.
Jesuscould heal him. (This event happened right after
Jesusmoved His ministry into the
wildernessbecause the crowds were getting too large to meet indoors. This is also when
Jesusattracted the religious leaders attention enough that they started sending members of their group to spy on Him.) The detailed analysis of these accounts is in the note for Luke 5:17. At the end of that analysis is the time sequence of events leading up to
Jesuscalling Matthew to discipleship. Please see that note in order to understand the time sequence which is reported.
Jesus, from all over, to be healed and have devils cast out. This was after He named the twelve who were to become apostles and just before He went up on the mount and preached the 'Sermon of the Mount'. As explained in the notes for these sentences, within the Book Study on the Gospel of Luke, these events give us the conception of the church which had its birth at Pentecost after the resurrection. The naming of the twelve give us the structure and authority for the early church. The 'Sermon of the Mount' give us His rules for people to follow when they become part of His church. In addition, we read about
Jesushealing many people and casting out many devils several other times and places.
Jesusdid this to show what was offered to people who accepted Him as their
King. As we know from all of the Gospel accounts, the Jews refused to do this and they lost all of these blessings. These additional references are: Matthew 8:16-17; Matthew 12:15-23; Matthew 14:14, Matthew 35-36; Matthew 15:30-31; Matthew 21:14; Mark 1:32-34, Mark 1:39, Mark 3:9-21 and Luke 4:40-41.
the scribes and the Phariseesstarted open war with
Jesus. Where, in the past, they were trying to hide their disagreement with Him and His doctrine, at this point they are no more hiding their disagreement.
And he went through the cities and villages, teaching, and journeying toward Jerusalem. This followed His making
all (the religious rulers) his adversaries were ashamedand His teaching on
the kingdom of God. That is: He taught the changes ('God's character in you today and the 1,000 years reign of
Christin the future') that God would expect in anyone who was truly saved during the 'Church Age'. He was teaching this as He
journeying toward Jerusalemfor the crucifixion and His paying the price for our salvation and to allow the start of the New Testament. Therefore, all teaching from this point until the crucifixion is the expectation of God for people saved under the New Testament.
Jesuspronounced judgment that would come upon Jerusalem because of the crucifixion. This is the start of events, in Luke's Gospel account, when we can know the actual time sequence of events. In the other Gospel accounts, we can not be sure of the time sequence until
Jesusarrives in Jerusalem for the last time.
Jesussaid:
Nevertheless I must walk to day, and to morrow, and the day following: for it cannot be that a prophet perish out of Jerusalem.The note for that sentence, in the Book Study on the Gospel of Luke, explains the
three daysand the references, in Luke's Gospel, which show us each of those days. While most of the Gospel of John deals with events and teaching by
Jesusonce He arrived at Jerusalem for this time, one third of Luke's gospel deals with the three day journey to get there and the events and teaching of
Jesusalong the way.
Jesusarrives in Jerusalem for the last time.
Jesuscured a man of dropsy. Please see the note for Matthew 12:8-LJC about how
Jesusdealt with the sabbath in the gospels.
Jesusinstructs the host Pharisee what is the godly attitude for dealing with others.
Jesusinstructs the
great multitudes with himwhat is required for them to become His disciple.
Jesussays:
So likewise, whosoever he be of you that forsaketh not all that he hath, he cannot be my disciple.
Jesusto His disciples with
the Pharisees and scribeslistening in. The last half of this chapter is directed to
the Pharisees and scribes. In everything said in this chapter
Jesussays that they, as lost religious people, have their reward in this world but face the judgment of God after death.
Jesuswas directly speaking to His disciples (16:1) but was actually indirectly speaking to the
Pharisees and scribes. He knew that they were listening in. Therefore, He could say things that they would object to if He said those things directly to the
Pharisees and scribes. However, since they were listening in on a conversation that he had with His disciples, they could not directly object at that time. Since this section is often misunderstood, the reader should read the detail notes for the sentences in this section in order to properly understand what was really going on.
Jesusreturned to speaking directly to the
Pharisees and scribesbecause
they derided himwhile others were listening.
Jesusdid not leave the other listeners wondering who told the truth.
Jesusfirst stated the motivations of their hearts which caused them to pervert God's law. Then He said that God's law never changed for any reason.
Jesusthen showed how they perverted God's law in a way that everyone understood their perversion. After these things, He gave the true account of Lazarus and the
rich manas a warning to them of their own personal fate if they continued to serve sin.
And the apostles said unto the Lord, Increase our faith. The answer from
Jesusis in Luke 17:7-10, which includes the 'Parable of the Unprofitable Servant'. That parable is also found in the Table of Parables in the NT.
Jesushealing ten (10) lepers. As explained in the note for this sentence, within the Book Study on the Gospel of Luke, miracles are reported in the Gospels when they provide a visible lesson which is related to the doctrine which is taught related to the miracle. The note for Mark 1:40-45 tells us every place in the Bible where we read forms of the word
leper.
Jesuson the kingdom of God.
Jesus, which is found in the found in the Prophecies Section of the Significant Gospel Events.
Jesusanswers questions about divorce. Although what Mark and Luke report are different things, both report teaching from
Jesusto His disciples. It is reasonable to believe both happened at the same relative time but each author chose to report only part of what was taught.
Jesusexplained God's opinion about
little children.
Jesusexplained about
inheriting eternal life.
Jesusexplained about
richesin this world.
Jesus, led to Peter asking about our heavenly rewards which
Jesusexplained in Matthew 19:27-30; Mark 10:28-31 and Luke 18:28-30. The answer given, is similar to what we read in Luke 22:28-30 and Hebrews 11:24-26, although the details are different.
Jesuswent to Jerusalem for the final confrontation and prophesied His betrayal, suffering and death while on the way to Jerusalem. Matthew 20:17-19 and Mark 10:32-34 tell the same things, and that the telling happened on the same trip, but may actually be different, repeated, messages from
Jesusto His disciples. This is also just before John 12 starts.
Jesusexplained how to be called great in His kingdom in Matthew 20:25-28; Mark 10:42-45; Luke 22:24-30 and John 13:12-15.
Jesushealing two blind men, one of whom was Bartimaeus.
Jesusentered Jerusalem in triumph. The sequence reported in the other Gospels make it appear as if these things happened later, but those Gospel reports do not give us an absolute time sequence. Therefore, there is room to argue that these events happened before
Jesusentered Jerusalem in triumph or they can be argued to happen after that event.
nigh. Matthew 26:1-2 and Mark 14:1 say that the Passover was in two (2) days. John 12:1 say that the Passover was in six (6) days. Therefore, the dinner could have happened in the four (4) days between the time that John reports and the time that Matthew and Mark report.
chief priests and the Phariseesplotted the death of
Jesus. However, since they, most assuredly, met more than once, the references to their meetings can actually be for different incidents.
Jesusand His disciples ate a meal at the house of Simon the leper and Mary Magdalene anointed
Jesusfor His death.
Jesusentered Jerusalem for the final conflict. During His trip to Jerusalem,
Jesustaught His disciples the difference between 'A fruitful religion versus a show religion'.
Jesusentered Jerusalem in triumph and the people cried
Hosanna to the Son of David: Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord; Hosanna in the highestand
Jesuswas
glorified. This is a fulfillment of Psalms 148; Isaiah 40:9 and Zechariah 9:9 which show us how they praised Him. In addition, Zechariah 9:9 tells us that He would be
riding upon an ass, and upon a colt the foal of an ass. Further, the prophecy for Judah, when Jacob died, includes:
The sceptre shall not depart from Judah, nor a lawgiver from between his feet, until Shiloh come; and unto him shall the gathering of the people be. Binding his foal unto the vine, and his ass's colt unto the choice vine; he washed his garments in wine, and his clothes in the blood of grapes: His eyes shall be red with wine, and his teeth white with milk.(Genesis 49:10-12).
Jesusprophesied that the disciples would find a colt tied, whereon never man sat. This is a fulfillment of Zechariah 9:9 and Psalms 148 which show us how they praised Him.
Jesusbeing
glorified.
Jesusbeing
glorified.
Jesuscursing the fig tree because it had no fruit.
Jesuscleaning the Temple. The chief priests sought to destroy
Jesusover this act.
Jesuscursing the fig tree because it had no fruit.
Jesustaught based upon the cursing of the fig tree.
Jesusas He taught in the Temple and this is reported in Matthew 21:23-27, Mark 11:27-33 and Luke 20:1-7. Please see the Doctrinal Document called What Did Jesus Do? for how this entire chapter is an example of how to handle conflict, especially conflict which is motivated by devils.
These words spake Jesus in the treasury, as he taught in the templeand the accounts in these other Gospels happened in the Temple and end with
Jesusbeing by the
treasury. In addition, while the specific accounts differ, all Gospels report the same types of incidents between the religious leaders and
Jesus.
Jesusresponded to
the chief priests, and the scribes, and the eldersin parables. With this consideration, we read in Matthew 21:33-46; Mark 12:2-11 and Luke 20:9-19 that
Jesusgive us the 'Parable of the Hirelings Killing the Heir'. Matthew 21:33-46 also tells us about the religious leaders killing the prophets.
the chief priests, and the scribes, and the elderstried to use others to destroy
Jesus. All failed.
the Herodianstried an argument about money and taxes.
the Sadduceestried an argument about the resurrection.
the scribestried an argument about the Mosaic Law. A parallel accounts can be found in Matthew 22:34-40.
And no man after that durst ask him any question.
Jesusasked
How say the scribes that Christ is the Son of David?.
Jesusreceives no answer from the religious leaders, He then talks to the general people and tells
Beware of the scribesin Matthew 23:1-12; Mark 12:38-40 and Luke 20:45-47.
two mitesin Mark 12:41-44 and Luke 21:1-4.
watch.
Jesusspent His days teaching in the Temple and the people heard Him gladly. While this report is unique to Luke, it is the same time period as we read in the other three Gospel accounts and which is between when
Jesusentered Jerusalem in triumph and the 'Last Supper'.
Prophecyand
Prophecy Fulfilled.
Jesussaid that He had the 'Last Supper' with the twelve before His crucifixion (
his hour was come that he should depart out of this world).
Jesus.
Jesusas reported in Matthew 26:14-16; Mark 14:10-11 and Luke 22:3-6..
Jesus. also prophesied of this in John 6:70-71.
Jesusas reported in Matthew 26:17-19; Mark 14:12-16 and Luke 22:7-13. John does not report the preparation but has far more about the actual 'Last Supper' than any other gospel writer.
Jesusprophesied what the disciples would find when they went to prepare the upper room for the
feast of unleavened bread. The sentence which follow the prophecy tell us that the prophecy was fulfilled exactly as
Jesussaid. The indication of the Gospel reports is that this was so common that the disciples expected the prophecy to be fulfilled exactly as
Jesussaid.
Jesusstarted at
even.
Jesusthat Judas would betray Him. In addition, the note for John 6:64 provides links to where every reference to this
betrayalcan be found in the Gospels.
Jesuscreated for us to remember Him and His suffering by. This celebration from the 'Last Supper' is commonly called
the Lord's Supper.
when they had sung an hymn, they went out into the mount of Olives.
Jesusprophesied His own crucifixion and that the disciples would
scatterbecause of the crucifixion.
Jesusthat all of the disciples would be offended by Him that night. There are several other prophecies in this chapter and they can be found in the Prophecies section.
Jesusprophesies Peter's denials as reported in Matthew 26:33-35; Mark 14:29-31; Luke 22:31-34 and John 13:37-38. The rest of the disciples also denied that they would scatter.
The detailed incidents of this event are in all Gospel accounts. However, the details vary between the various gospels because the different authors present different points of view. There are no conflicts between the Gospels on these incidents.
the chief priests, and the scribes, and the elderstried to use others to destroy
Jesus. In the start of that section, within Luke's Gospel account, we read
so they might deliver him unto the power and authority of the governor. Even though the religious leaders had some civil authority, they could not sentence someone to death. But, the
governorcould. Therefore, this is when they decided to kill
Jesus.
Jesuschanged the instruction from how God's preachers were to go out and represent the Gospel during the 'Church Age'. In the past, while they were going to Jews only and only within the country of the Jews, they were to take nothing and rely on God to move Jews to provide for their physical needs. Now, when going to strangers in strange cultures, they were to take provision with them.
Jesusgoing to Gethsemane. (Although Luke 22:39 calls it
the mount of Olives.) These accounts are found in Matthew 26:36-46; Mark 14:32-42; Luke 22:39-53 and John 18:1-13. The reader can search these accounts for uniquely reported events such as the fact that
there appeared an angel unto him from heaven, strengthening him.(Luke 22:43-44).
Jesus, and the eleven, went to the
garden of Gethsemane. There,
Jesusleft most in one place, took Peter, James and John further and left them and went, by Himself, further to pray. At each spot,
Jesustold His disciples to pray that they not enter into temptation.
Jesusis reported in: Matthew 26:39; Matthew 26:42; Matthew 26:44; Mark 14:36 and Luke 22:41-42.
Jesusfinding the disciples asleep three times when they were supposed to be praying. Judas Iscariot came with the mob while
Jesustalked to them the third time.
Jesusis reported in: Matthew 26:47-50; Mark 14:43-46; Luke 22:47-54 and John 18:2-13.
Jesus. Those references also tell us about
Jesushealing the man. Some of the details are only told in one of the Gospels. This event is also found in the Table of Miracles within the Gospels.
Jesusfound in Matthew 26:31 and Mark 14:27. Mark's account also tells us that Mark started to follow but ran after his robe was grabbed. In addition, Luke 22:54 reports:
And Peter followed afar off. Further, John 18:16 reports:
But Peter stood at the door without.. Therefore, since Peter was outside of where
Jesuswas taken, we can know that he followed but did not stay with
Jesus.
Jesusis taken before Annas the high priest as reported in: John 18:12-24.
Jesusis taken before Caiaphas the high priest as reported in: Matthew 26:57; Mark 14:53; Luke 22:54 and John 18:24-28.
Jesusby Caiaphas and the scribes and elders and the
council.
Jesusby Caiaphas and the scribes and elders and the
council, we see them trying to get
Jesusto make a statement which they can use to bring a false charge against Him. John 18:19-18:23 has questioning which is only recorded in John. This questioning was done either before or after the seeking of false witnesses recorded in Matthew 26:59-63 and Mark 14:55-60.
false witnesses.
Jesusrefused to answer anything until they asked Him:
Art thou the Christ, the Son of the Blessed?.
Jesusdirectly answered that He was God's
Christ. Please see the Prophecy Fulfilled Section, and other Sections of the Significant Gospel Events Study, for other references to this truth. John 10:24 also has the same question and answer but it was an earlier time in the ministry of
Jesus. Therefore, they already had this answer but it was not given during an official trial like the later event was during an official trial.
Jesusof His return to this Earth. There are several other prophecies in this chapter and they can be found in the Prophecies Section of this Study.
Jesusof blaspheme because He answered their question honestly. They condemned Him for doing exactly what God's word taught that God's
Christwould do.
Jesus.
began to spit on him, and to cover his face, and to buffet him, and to say unto him, Prophesy: and the servants did strike him with the palms of their hands.
Jesusas reported in: Matthew 26:69-75; Mark 14:66-72; Luke 22:56-62; John 18:15-18 and John 18:25-27. Each of the Gospels give us some details about this event which are not in the other Gospels. Piecing these accounts together we see that it was two servant maids and a guard who questioned Peter. The first maid also opened the door for John and Peter.
High priest.
Jesus, done by Pilate and Herod.
Jesuswas sent to Pilate for a judgment of death since it was not lawful for the Jews to give a death sentence. There is quite a lot, in all of the Gospels, about this judgment. The accounts start with the references provided and some of the details are reported in one account but not in others. Please see the note for John 18:29 which has the time-line for this trial that comes from the International Standard Bible Encyclopedia.
Jesuswas sent to Pilate after His trial by the Jews.
Jesus.In John 18:29-32 we read that Pilate asked them what they accused
Jesusof and they replied
If he were not a malefactor, we would not have delivered him up unto thee. However, that just calls Him a criminal and is not a true accusation of a specific crime like is required in a court of law. We continue to read how Pilate trued to refuse to judge
Jesus, but eventually agreed to their demands.
Jesusby Pilate.
Jesus: and the various Gospel accounts tell us different details. The accounts start with Pilate asking
Jesus:
Art thou the King of the Jews?The answer is reported in Matthew 27:11; Mark 15:2; Luke 23:3 and John 18:34. The answer from
Jesus, in every Gospel account, is almost the same words(
Thou sayest it), except that John relates more of the conversation. Supposedly, that phrase (
Thou sayest it) is a figure-of-speech which means: 'This is a truth which has no valid questioning against it'.
Jesusanswered nothing to the accusations which the religious leaders brought against Him when He was tried by the civil authorities.
Jesusas part of an annual release of one criminal by the Roman government.
chasten
Jesusand then release Him. While the statement from Pilate is not in the other Gospel accounts, the offer from Pilate, to release
Jesus, was also reported in: Matthew 27:15 and John 18:39. This was when they stirred up the people to demand Barabbas instead.
Jesusin: Matthew 27:16-26; Mark 15:7-15; Luke 23:17-25; John 18:40 and Acts 3:14.
Jesus. The first time is also when Luke reports that Pilate called the Jewish leaders and said that he would beat
Jesusand then release Him. This was when the Jewish religious leaders stirred up the people to demand Barabbas instead (Luke 23:13-16).
Have thou nothing to do with that just man: for I have suffered many things this day in a dream because of him.
Jesusas reported in Matthew 27:21-25; Mark 15:9-14; Luke 23:18; John 18:40 and as reported in John 19:14-15. This was after Pilate declared
Jesusto be innocent.
spake again to them), that Pilate spoke and tried to avoid crucifying
Jesus. This was also when Pilate tried an appeal to the masses to not crucify their
Messiah / Christ, Who would also be their
King.
the third time, (Matthew 27:22; Mark 15:12; Luke 23:22 and John 19:14) Pilate tried again. The three times lets us know that Pilate was, symbolically, speaking for God and their three rejections would be used by God when he legally judged them for their rejection of
Jesusas their
King. Thus, we see that Pilate tried more than once and more than one way to keep from crucifying
Jesus. However, Pilate eventually did, and was found guilty by God even though he, symbolically,
washed his hands and said I am innocent of the blood of this just person(Matthew 27:24).
His blood be on us, and on our children(Matthew 27:25).
Jesusto death. This was after Pilate declared
Jesusto be innocent in John 19:4, John 19:6 and Luke 23:4.
Jesuswas
scourged.
Jesusprophesized that this would happen in Matthew 20:19.
Jesus,
I find no fault in this man. His pronouncement did not make him innocent and, since he represented the government of this world, we see that the governments of this world were as guilty as the Jews for the crucifixion of
Jesus. Pilate tried to free Jesus again in Luke 23:16 and John 19:14-15. This second time was after Pilate declared
Jesusto be innocent.
Jesus.
Jesusto Herod for trial. Only in Luke 23:8-12 do we read about the trial of
Jesusby Herod. Herod did not do the judgment for Pilate although Herod and his men did abuse
Jesus.
scourgingreported in John 19:1-5 occurs at this time. This is different from what happens after Pilate condemns
Jesusto be crucified. Pilate did this then brought
Jesusback before the crowd wearing a crown of thorns and tried to release Him again. But the religious leaders stirred up the crowd to demand
crucify Him.
Jesuswas more than 'just a human man' but it was too late for his personal salvation. There are also other incidents in John's Gospel, which occur at this time, and the detail notes for the Book Study on John's Gospel.
Jesuswas in Pilate's judgment hall at least three times: before being sent to Herod, before being beat and given a crown of thorns, and before being sent to be crucified. This fulfills the prophecy by
Jesusfound in Matthew 26:31 and Mark 14:27 and John 16:32. This also matches Luke 23:22 where we read:
he (Pilate) said unto them the third time.
crucify him.
Jesusto death. Further, Luke 23:24 reports
Pilate gave sentence that it should be as they required. These references give us the reports of the official legal judgment by the Roman Government. This was after Pilate declared
Jesusto be innocent in John 19:4; John 19:6 and Luke 23:4.
Jesuswas taken to be mocked and crucified.
chasten
Jesusand let Him go.
Jesusand then brought
Jesusback before the crowd wearing a crown of thorns and tried to release Him again. But the religious leaders stirred up the crowd to demand
crucify Him.
Jesuswas led from the Roman judgment seat to be crucified. Between the judgment hall and the cross He was beaten by the Roman soldiers. This fulfills the prophecy by
Jesusfound in Matthew 26:31 and Mark 14:27 and John 16:32.
Jesusmore after the Jews told Pilate that
Jesuswas
the Son of God. In the end, when the Jews threatened Pilate's position in the Roman government, Pilate sent
Jesusto be crucified.
clothed him with purple/
put on him a scarlet robeas a mockery of His being
King of the Jews. In addition, Matthew 27:31 and Mark 15:20 tell us that they, later, took it off. It is possible that this happened twice and it is possible that it happened once and either Mark or John reports the event out of time sequence. Please remember that none of the Gospel authors stick to a strict time sequence in their accounts. In addition, the notes for Matthew explain the different colors reported.
crown of thornswas put on the head of
Jesus.
Jesuswas taken to be crucified.
laid hold upon one Simon, a Cyrenian, coming out of the country, and on him they laid the cross, that he might bear it after Jesusin Matthew 27:32; Mark 15:21 and Luke 23:26.
Jesuswas crucified at
Golgothain Matthew 27:33; Mark 15:27 and John 19:17. Luke 23:33 tells us the same thing only uses the name of
Calvaryfor the same place.
Jesusgave them a prophecy of future judgment upon the Jews.
Jesus.
Jesuswas given vinegar to drink while on the cross. Matthew 27:34; and probably, Luke 23:36-37 tell us that it was
mingled with gall: and when he had tasted thereof, he would not drink. This is assumed to be because
galldulled the senses and it was offered to Him as an insult. However, when it was offered plain, as in the other references,
Jesusdid drink.
Jesuswas on the cross as reported in Matthew 27:35-50; Mark 15:23-37; Luke 23:32-46 and as reported in John 19:17-30.
sitting down they watched him there.
JESUS, in all capitals. This capitalization directly ties these verses together, and also ties this verse to the name
Saviour.
Jesusamong themselves. Spoils were considered normal part of a soldier's pay at that time.
Jesus. John 19:21-22 tells us that
the chief priests of the Jewsobjected to the truth of the title and wanted it changed to support their lie but Pilate refused to change the superscription.
Jesuswas crucified between two
malefactors.
And the scripture was fulfilled, which saith, And he was numbered with the transgressors.. Please see that note in the Bible Study for the prophecy references.
Jesus. However, John 19:25-27 tells us about the loved ones of
Jesusbeing there and
Jesustalking to them.
darkness over the whole land (from the sixth hour) until the ninth hour. The fact that this incident is reported in three Gospel accounts makes it very important. In addition, the fact that it was prophesied also makes it important. It was prophesied in: Psalms 105:28; Joel 2:31; Amos 5:18; Amos 8:9 and Habakkuk 3:11. In addition, it is related to one of the plagues on Egypt found in Exodus 10:21-23. Further, it foreshadows Revelation 6:12 and Revelation 8:12.
Jesuswhile He was on the cross. Other reports of the soldiers mocking Him were before the crucifixion.
Jesusliterally physically died and that He chose the time of His death. In John 10:15 and John 10:17
Jesusprophesied that He would
lay down my life. In addition, we also have prophecies in the Old Testament in: Exodus 12:46; Numbers 9:12; Psalms 22:14; Psalms 22:16-17; Psalms 34:20 and Zechariah 12:10.
the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom.
when the centurion saw what was done, he glorified God, saying, Certainly this was a righteous man.
saw the earthquake, and those things that were done, (and) they feared greatly.
Jesusat the cross.
high sabbath, and not a Saturday, as many people assume and many religions teach wrongly. And, since it was
the preparation (for that sabbath day which was an high day), that the bodies should not remain upon the cross on the sabbath day. Therefore, the Jews requested that they break the legs of those crucified so that they died quicker and their bodies be taken down before the sabbath. (This is explained in the other Gospel accounts but is not reported by Luke.) However,
when they came to Jesus, and saw that he was dead already, they brake not his legs: But one of the soldiers with a spear pierced his side, and forthwith came there out blood and water. After Pilate verified that
Jesuswas dead, he released the body.
Jesuswas buried as reported in Matthew 27:57-61; Mark 15:42-47; Luke 23:50-56 and John 19:38-42.
Joseph of Arimathaea, is named in all four (4) Gospel accounts in: Matthew 27:57; Mark 15:43; Luke 23:50-51 and John 19:38
went unto Pilate, and begged the body of Jesus.
took they the body of Jesus, and wound it in linen clothes with the spicesand that where they put
the body of Jesuswas in a garden.
the body of Jesusinto a
sepulchre that was hewn in stone, wherein never man before was laidIn addition, they
rolled a great stone to the door of the sepulchre, and departed.
sepulchreare mentioned in: Matthew 27:61; Mark 15:42-47 and Luke 23:55.
The events of the Resurrection of Jesus have parallel accounts in all of the Gospels but the details vary between the various gospels because the different authors present different points of view. There are no conflicts between the Gospels on these events. Below is the sequence of events, after the body of Jesus
was put into the sepulchre
, as I understand them. In certain cases, the explanations of how events fit together, without causing conflicts, are in the detail notes for the Book Studies on the various Gospels, especially in the notes for the Gospel of Mark. Please use the links provided to see the referenced notes for further details as needed.
Jesuswould be in the grave
three days and three nights.
Jesusand the time following, but each of those chapters bring out different significant details. The actual resurrection account is at the beginning of each of the chapters mentioned.
Jesusis reported, within the New Testament, in Matthew 12:40; Matthew 16:21; Matthew 17:9; Matthew 26:32; Matthew 28:1-10; Mark 9:9; Mark 16:1-9, Luke 9:22; 24:1-12, 24:34; John 2:19, 2:22; 6:62; John 10:17-19; 12:23; 13:31; John 20:1-10 and John 21:14. We also find references to this event in: Acts 2:24, 30, 32-36; 3:15, 26; 4:10; 5:30-31; 10:40; 13:30, 33, 34, 37; 17:3, 31; Romans 4:24, 25; 6:4, 9; 7:4; 8:11, 34; 9:10; 1Corinthians 6:14; 15:14, 15, 16, 17, 20; Galatians 1:1; Ephesians 1:20; Ephesians 2:6; Colossians 2:12; 3:1; 1Thessalonians 1:10; 2Timothy 2:8; Titus 2:10-14; Hebrews 11:19 and 1Peter 1:21.
Jesusas
Lordand God. These are in Matthew 28:6; Mark 16:19; Mark 16:20; Luke 24:3; Luke 24:34; John 20:2; John 20:13; John 20:18; John 20:20; John 20:25; John 20:28; John 21:7; John 21:7; John 21:12; John 21:15; John 21:16; John 21:17; John 21:20; John 21:21; Acts 2:36. These verse is parallel to Luke 24:51-53 and Acts 1:1-12 where we are told that the disciples
worshippedthe risen
Lord.
And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose, And came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared unto many.
sepulchreon the
first day of the week.
there was a great earthquake: for the angel of the Lord descended from heaven, and came and rolled back the stone from the door, and sat upon it...And for fear of him the keepers did shake, and became as dead menBack in Matthew 27:62-66, we were told that the Jewish leaders requested a
watchon the
sepulchrebecause
Jesussaid that He would rise from the dead and they wanted to assure that there was no fraudulent claim of resurrection. Pilate granted their request. What is important for this sentence is that the
watchwere pretending to be dead when the women arrived. Therefore, the
watchdid not answer any questions. At some point the
watchleft but at no point does it appear that they interacted with any believer.
found the stone rolled away from the sepulchre. It would appear that they did not witness the angel rolling away the stone.
runneth, and cometh to Simon Peter and (John) and saith unto them, They have taken away the Lord out of the sepulchre, and we know not where they have laid him. Apparently, Mary Magdalene left while the other women were still outside trying to decide what to do.
sepulchre, saw that the body of
Jesuswas gone,
as they were much perplexed thereabout, behold, two men stood by them in shining garments: And as they were afraid, and bowed down their faces to the earth, and, apparently, while they were bowed, one of the angels sat down. Then the angels delivered their message to the women that
He is risen. Please see above for many Bible references to this fact. John 20:1-18 does not say it literally but delivers the same message in a less direct manner
sepulchreand saw
a young man sitting on the right side, clothed in a long white garment. Apparently, the women who came with Mary Magdalene decided to do this after she left to get Peter and John. We are also told that the angel spoke to the women, gave them a message to deliver to the apostles and told them to go. The wording of the message is slightly different between the two Gospels but the message is, essentially, the same. Apparently, all the women who were there obeyed the angel. However, since Mary Magdalene was busy getting Peter and John, she wasn't with these other women at the time of these events. Apparently, Mary Magdalene had come with the other women but ran to tell Peter and John that the body of
Jesuswas gone from the
sepulchre. She did not wait and enter the
sepulchre. with the other women. Therefore, she missed the message from the
angel. After telling Peter and John, she returned to the
sepulchrewhere
Jesusmet her and spoke to her personally.
It was Mary Magdalene, and Joanna, and Mary the mother of James, and other women that were with them, which told these things unto the apostles. And their words seemed to them as idle tales, and they believed them not.
Jesusmet the other women and gave them a similar message as the angel gave to them at the
sepulchre. This appearance was after He dealt with Mary Magdalene. Please see the note for John 20:17 for the explanation of this truth.
sepulchreand then
went away again unto their own home. They, apparently, later returned to the upper room later the same day because they were there when
Jesusappeared there later that same day.
Jesusdealing with Mary Magdalene in a personal way. Apparently, she returned to the sepulchre by following Peter and John and stayed when they left. While she was going to get Peter and John, the other women decided what they would do as told in the next few references. Apparently, they were gone by the time that Peter and John arrived and the two groups did not meet in the way.
Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene. Therefore, the events reported in John 20; which tell us about
Jesusdealing with Mary Magdalene, occur before
Jesusmet the other women and gave them a similar message as the angel gave to them at the
sepulchre. The other women had left the sepulchre and were heading back while
Jesusdealt with Mary Magdalene. He then dealt with the other women after dealing with Mary Magdalene but before they returned to the upper room.
that she had seen the Lord, and that he had spoken these things unto her. Mark 16:10-11 reports
And she went and told them that had been with him, as they mourned and wept. And they, when they had heard that he was alive, and had been seen of her, believed not.
watchreported what happened
unto the chief priests, who paid then to lie about what happened.
They have taken away the Lord out of the sepulchre, and we know not where they have laid him. As a result, Peter and John ran to the
sepulchre, inspected it and then
went away again unto their own home. Now we see Mary Magdalene, with the other women, report that
Jesuswas alive and the eleven refused to believe (Mark 16:10-11; Luke 24:11 and John 20:18). As a result, Luke 24:12 says:
Then arose Peter, and ran unto the sepulchre; and stooping down, he beheld the linen clothes laid by themselves, and departed, wondering in himself at that which was come to pass.Apparently, this was a second visit to the
sepulchreby Peter.(John 20:3-10)
After that he appeared in another form unto two of them, as they walked, and went into the country.Luke 24:13-31 tells us the same thing only with much more detail. Then Luke 24:22-24 makes it clear that this happened after the women brought their report to the upper room and after Peter was told about the risen
Lord Jesus, for the second time, and he returned to the sepulchre. In addition, Luke 24:38-49 makes it clear that this happened before
Jesusappeared in the upper room for the first time.
neither believed they them.
Jesusappeared to a Simon who may or may not have been Peter. At this time, the
elevenwere in the upper-room and had not seen the resurrected
Lord Jesusbut were about to see Him.
Jesusappeared in the upper room. Luke's account provides much more detail than the other Gospel accounts. When
Jesusappeared in the upper room, He
upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.
Jesusappeared in the upper room, but tell us about
Jesus, at that time, going out and returning to Heaven. Therefore, with what we read elsewhere in the Bible, there must be a time gap of several days between these two sections of the Gospel of Luke. Therefore, time wise, this reference is that the end of all Gospel accounts..
Jesusreturned
after eight daysand dealt with Thomas.
Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them. After that Matthew doesn't tell us any more events which fit into the sequence but ends his Gospel with his portion of the 'Great Commission'. Their going to Galilee, appears to be after the first day of the resurrection of
Jesus. This is, apparently, when John 21 occurs. It also appears that the disciples returned to the upper room and were there when
Jesusreturned to Heaven (Acts 1) and when the Holy Ghost was given to them (Acts 2).
Jesuscommissioned the apostles, and us, to do the 'Great Commission', as reported in Matthew 28:18-19; Mark 16:15-18; Luke 24:45-49 and Acts 1:8.
Acts 1:3 says: To whom also he shewed himself alive after his passion by many infallible proofs, being seen of them forty days, and speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God
. Thus, we have forty days
between when Jesus
first appeared in the upper-room and when He returned to Heaven. We also know that the disciples were in the upper-room on the day of the resurrection and they were there on the day that Jesus
returned to Heaven. However, Matthew 28:16 says: Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them.
So, how long they were away is not revealed. In addition, John 21 tells us about Peter leading several of the other disciples to return to their jobs in the world as fishermen. So, we also know that they left for these two incidents, but the Gospel accounts do not tell us about any of the other time as to where they were or what they did. This makes it impossible to provide an exact time sequence for these forty days. The events which are reported to have happened during these forty days are doctrinally important by themselves without us knowing the time sequence of when they happened. Therefore, God does not provide this information.
The resurrection of Christ
and of all men was prophesied in several verses including: Genesis 3:15; Genesis 22:18; Genesis 26:4; Genesis 49:10; Exodus 3:6; Exodus 3:16; Numbers 21:6-9; Deuteronomy 18:15; Job 14:13-15; Job 16:9-10; Job 19:23-29; Job 30:9-14; Psalms 16:9; Psalms 16:10; Psalms 16:11; Psalms 17:15; Psalms 22:6-7; Psalms 22:13; Psalms 35:15-16; Psalms 35:25; Psalms 49:15; Psalms 69:7-12; Psalms 71:20; Psalms 132:11; Isaiah 7:14; Isaiah 9:6-7; Isaiah 26:19; Isaiah 28:5; Isaiah 40:10-11; Isaiah 49:7; Isaiah 50:6-7; Isaiah 52:13-14; Isaiah 52:53; Isaiah 53:3; Jeremiah 23:5-6; Jeremiah 33:14-15; Lamentations 52:14; Ezekiel 34:23; Ezekiel 37:1-14; Ezekiel 37:25; Daniel 9:24-26; Daniel 12:2-3; Daniel 12:13; 6:2; Hosea 13:14; Micah 5:1-4; Micah 7:20; Zechariah 9:9; Zechariah 13:7; Malachi 3:1-3; Malachi 4:2. Further, we read about the resurrection of the dead in Matthew 22:23-32; Matthew 24:31; Matthew 25:1-13; Matthew 27:52-53; Mark 12:18-27; Luke 14:14; 20:27-38; John 5:21; John 5:25; John 5:28-29; John 6:39-40; John 6:44; John 6:54; 11:23-25; 14:19; Acts 2:26-31; 4:1-2; 24:15; 17:18; 32; 23:6; 8; 24:14-15; 26:6-8; Romans 4:16-21; 8:10-11; 19; 21-23; 1Corinthians 6:14; 15:12-32; 35-57; 2Corinthians 4:14; 5:1-5; Philippians 3:10-11; 21; 1Thessalonians 4:14; 16; 2Thessalonians 1:10; 2Timothy 2:18; Hebrews 6:2; 11:19; 35; Revelation 1:18; 20:4-6; 13. Therefore, these references should be used to comfort the saints about God's repeated promise of our own resurrection.
We find the Bible uses Jesus
and rise / raised
together, to speak about the resurrection of someone else (done by Jesus
) in Luke 7:22; John 12:1; John 12:9; Ephesians 2:6. In addition, the Table Of Miracles provides links the places where the Gospels tell us about Jesus
raising the dead 3 times.
Jesusappeared after His resurrection to Mary Magdalene as reported in Mark 16:9-11 and John 20:14-17.
Jesusappeared after His resurrection to the other women, who had gone to the sepulchre early in the morning, as reported in Matthew 28:9-10.
Jesusappeared after His resurrection to the two disciples on the road to Emmaus as reported in Mark 16:12-13 and Luke 24:13-31.
Jesusappeared to a Simon who may, or may not, have been Peter. This was reported in Luke 24:33-34.
Jesusappeared to Peter as reported in 1Corinthians 15:5.
Jesusappeared after His resurrection to the eleven apostles as reported in Mark 16:14; Luke 24:36-49 and John 20:19.
Jesusappeared to the eleven apostles, again, a week later as reported in John 20:26.
Jesusappeared to Peter, John and several other disciples, when they went fishing, as reported in John 21. We are told that this was the third appearance to the group of disciples, who would become apostles, but that does not count His appearing to individuals or to others.
Jesustold the disciples to meet Him in Galilee. That section also tells us that they met there.
Jesusappeared, on several different occasions, to several different believers as reported in 1Corinthians 15:3-8.
Jesusappeared after His resurrection to the eleven apostles as reported in Mark 16:14-18.
Jesuscommissioned them, and us, to do the 'Great Commission', as reported in Matthew 28:18-20; Mark 16:15-20; Luke 24:45-49 and Acts 1:8.
Jesusappeared to the apostles when He ascended into Heaven as reported in Mark 16:19; Luke 24:50-53. We also have appearances in Acts 1:4 and Acts 9:3; which have to be added to that Study when it is completed.